The hard years usually belong in a family memoir about a parent: the illness, the death that changed the house, the money that went, the fight between brothers. Leave them out and the good years stop making sense. The parent decides how much goes in and in what words, and whatever they hold back stays out.
That last part is not a courtesy. It is the method. On my own pages I put it this way: what goes in is a craft choice you make together, and what stays out is a moral one (Why confidentiality matters). This post is about both halves, for a son or daughter writing about a living parent.
If you are writing your own memoir, the question runs the other way, and I have a separate guide on what to leave out of your autobiography.
Why do the hard years belong in a family memoir?
The hard years belong in the book because a life told only through its good years reads like a brochure, and the children reading it learn nothing from it about getting through.
There is research behind this, and it is worth reading with its limits. In 2001, the Emory University psychologists Marshall Duke and Robyn Fivush asked about four dozen families a set of 20 yes-or-no questions about family history, the “Do You Know?” scale. One of them asks whether you know the lessons your parents learned from good or bad experiences. Children who knew more scored higher on self-esteem and a sense of control over their lives. The peer-reviewed paper (Duke, Lazarus and Fivush, Psychotherapy, 2008) says knowledge of family history is “significantly correlated” with those measures.
Bruce Feiler’s 2013 New York Times column on the study (his own repost of it) described three kinds of family story. The rising one: we came with nothing and built this. The falling one: we had it all and lost it. And the one that goes up and down: we had good years and bad years, and we stayed together through them. Duke told him the third is “the most healthful”. After 9/11, the children who knew more about their families “proved to be more resilient.”
Three caveats, because they matter:
- It is correlation, not proof. Knowing the stories goes with doing well. It does not show the stories cause it.
- The samples are small. About 48 families in the first round, a small American sample. Whether it holds the same way for Indian families has not been tested in anything I read.
- The facts are not the point. Duke wrote in 2013 that “simply knowing the answers” will not produce the good outcomes. Fivush wrote in 2016 that what matters is “the process of families sharing stories.” The talking is the thing. The book is what keeps it.
So the case for the hard years is not that pain is good reading. A parent’s book with the bad year in it tells a grandchild something true: this family had a bad year, and here is how it got through.
What counts as the hard years?
Most hard years in a parent’s life fall into five kinds, and each one asks something different of the book.
| The hard year | What it often holds | Who else it touches | What the book usually needs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Illness | A diagnosis, a hospital, a long recovery or none | The spouse who nursed, the children who were sent away | The person during it, not the medical file |
| A death | A parent, a spouse, a child, a sibling | Everyone who grieved, often differently | Who they were, what changed in the house after |
| Money | A business that failed, a debt, a job lost at 50 | Partners, lenders, the children’s schooling | What was decided, and what it cost the family |
| A family fight | A partition of the business or the house, a brother not spoken to | Living relatives with their own version | Both accounts, or the parent’s account clearly marked as theirs |
| The move | Leaving a town, a country, a language | Those left behind | What was given up, as well as what was gained |
The table is a starting map, not a rule. In one family the move is the whole book. In another the money year is a page.
Free printable: 100 questions to ask your parents
Ten sessions, ten questions each, in the order that gets a parent talking. Print it, take it home, tick them off as you go. Leave your email and download it straight away.
How do you ask a parent about illness and loss?
Ask him late, ask him once, and tell him before you start that he can refuse any question or stop the recording at any time.
Oral history guides put this first, and it holds at a dining table as much as in an archive. The Oral History Association’s ethics statement says the interviewer must “communicate the narrator’s right to refuse to answer questions”. The US National Park Service guide on difficult topics puts it more bluntly: it is the narrator’s “absolute right, at any point, to stop the recording.” The same guide adds a line every son and daughter should read: “oral history is not therapy, and you are not a therapist.”
What that looks like in practice:
- Save the hard questions for later sessions. In my 100 questions for parents, the loss questions sit in session nine of ten (100 questions to ask your parents). By then he trusts the recorder and you.
- Agree the finish time first. The UK Oral History Society suggests agreeing in advance “a time to finish the recording session, or perhaps to arrange to have a break.” A hard session should end when it was meant to, not when he runs out.
- Start and end on easier ground. Voice of Witness, which records difficult testimony, advises beginning and ending “with more comfortable, casual conversation.” A photograph from the good year is a fine way out.
- Ask about the people, not the diagnosis. “Who sat with you in the hospital?” opens more than “What did the doctors say?”
- If he cries, wait. The Park Service guide says to give the narrator “respectful time to recover with dignity.” Do not rush to the next question, and do not switch the recorder off unless he asks.
- If he says “don’t put this in”, keep recording unless he asks you to stop. Note it, mark it, and honour it later. The recording is not the book.
If the parent has dementia, the rules bend further. I have written on that in my answers to families’ questions: sessions follow the person, and some days will not work.
For more questions that open the harder ground slowly, the 20 questions to ask your father end with a set kept for when you are both ready.
How do you write a family fight without taking sides?
Write a family fight as two accounts, or as one account clearly labelled as hers, never as the settled truth.
A fight between living relatives is the hard year most likely to hurt someone after the book is printed. My published rule for it, on the answers page: the book holds both accounts and cites the document where one exists, because picking one version and printing it is how family books start arguments that outlast the people in them.
Three ways to do that on the page:
- Mark the voice. “This is how my mother remembers the summer the shop was divided.” The reader knows whose memory it is.
- Give the other side its dignity. Name what the uncle wanted, not only what he did.
- Show it to the people in it. The UK Oral History Society says that people named in a recording can object to it being made public, and that custodians should give their objections “careful and sympathetic consideration”. A family book should do no less.
If she wants the fight told and her brother would be hurt by it, that is not a writing problem. It is a family decision, and it gets made before the book is printed, not after.
How much of the book should the hard years take?
The hard years usually take a chapter, not the book, and in a short book of a dozen stories, one or two of them.
The gift book I write holds 10 to 12 stories in about 25,000 words (the gift book). If his illness takes four of the twelve, the book becomes a book about the illness, and he becomes a patient in his own life story. Most parents do not want that, and they will tell you so.
Some practical measures:
- Give the hard year its proportion of the life. Two bad years in eighty get a chapter. A decade of caring for a sick wife may get three.
- Tell it as a scene. The night the phone rang. The ward. The drive home. One scene carries more than a page of summary.
- End the chapter where the family went next. That is the up-and-down story in its plainest form.
Who decides what stays out?
The parent decides what stays out, and everyone else gets to see it before it is printed.
On the gift book, the parent decides what stays out. That is written into the offer, not left to goodwill. In a full family book, the family reviews every section and nothing reaches the page they have not seen (family legacy books).
Between printing a chapter and cutting it, there is a third option, taken from oral history. The Oral History Association’s ethics statement says a narrator may keep an interview closed “until a set date”. A family can do the same: record the hard chapter, write it, and keep it out of the printed copies, sealed with the recordings, for the grandchildren to open later. The story is kept. Nobody is hurt this year.
| Option | What the family gets | When it fits |
|---|---|---|
| Print it | The whole life, now | The parent wants it told and nobody named will be wounded |
| Print it, softened | The event, without the detail | The fact matters more than the particulars |
| Record it, seal it | The story kept for later | The people it touches are still alive |
| Leave it out | Nothing on paper | The parent says no. That ends it |
From the desk
I wrote on my confidentiality page that the hardest question in this work is what stays out, and that a good writer gives that decision as much weight as the prose.
My published answer has two halves. What goes in is a craft choice made together. What stays out is a moral one, and it is yours alone. A memoir that hurts people by accident is a planning failure, as I put it on the answers page. Do not call it honesty.
We agree the boundaries early, and nothing reaches the page that the family has not seen.
Questions people ask
What if my parent wants to leave out something I think matters?
It stays out. Ask once why, and say why it matters to you, then accept the answer. You can record it and seal it if both of you agree, but a book made over a parent’s objection is no longer their book.
What if a sibling objects to a chapter?
Show the sibling the chapter before it is printed, and listen. Often the fix is to mark the account as the parent’s memory rather than the family’s verdict. If it cannot be fixed, the sealed copy is the middle path.
Should a parent’s book say how someone died?
Only as far as the parent wants it said. Most families find the cause matters less to the reader than what the person was like and what changed after. A tribute book for a parent who has died follows the same rule, with the family deciding.
Is it all right to make my parent cry in an interview?
Tears are not a sign that something went wrong. Stop if he asks, wait if he does not, and end the session on easier ground. If the memories stay heavy for days, that is beyond what a family interview should carry, and a counsellor is the right person to talk to.
If you are making the book yourself, the twelve steps to writing your parents’ life story take you from the first conversation to the printed copies.

Leave a Reply